** Steel Company (hereinafter referred to as the demander) signed a contract with ** Machinery Manufacturing Company (hereinafter referred to as the supplier) in 2021 and ordered a total of 15 units of two different models of "iron ladle capping devices (machine)" to be installed on the hot metal frame. After the equipment involved in the case was delivered, after repeated debugging by the supplier, the buyer believed that the equipment still had problems such as dimensions, material structure, and certain safety defects that were inconsistent with the agreement, and the equipment could not be used normally.
In order to clarify whether there are quality problems with the quality of the "iron ladle capping device (machine)" involved in the case, the buyer submitted an application for quality appraisal of the "iron ladle capping device (machine)".
appraisal analysis results: The
appraisal analysis expert group discussed the relevant information and on-site investigation of the iron ladle capping device involved in the case and made a comprehensive quality and technical analysis, and made the following suggestions and conclusions:
1, the two types of "iron ladle capping devices" involved in the case, when the cover is open, the rotating arm will block the protective shed and compress the escape space for personnel, which does not meet the standard GB 5083-1999 "General Principles for Safety and Hygiene Design of Production Equipment", there are potential safety hazards;
2, the fixing method of the two types of "iron ladle capping devices" involved in the case on the molten iron frame, the manufacturing method of the rotating frame, and the materials of the insulation cover and rotating arm do not meet the requirements of the "Technical Agreement";
3 , the material of the fuel tank and the hydraulic valve brand of the two types of "iron ladle capping device" involved in the case comply with the requirements of the "technical agreement", but the selection of the oil pump brand does not meet the requirements of the "technical agreement";
4, under the relevant requirements of the "Tendering Technical Documents", the height and width dimensions of the "** type iron ladle capping device" involved in the case do not meet the requirements of the "technical agreement".