"According to the information provided by the client, the demander and supplier signed a "Purchase Contract". The subject matter was 12 low-pressure vessels and towers (composite panels), including the "vacuum distillation tower and vacuum stripping tower" involved in the case. The contract equipment started to be used, and the demander discovered that the "manholes of the vacuum distillation tower and vacuum stripping tower" involved in the case (hereinafter referred to as "the case involved") The flange cover and flange stainless steel lining of "Manhole" appeared to have problems such as bulging and deformation in many places. After repair and repair by the supplier, the above-mentioned problems still appeared in the lining of the "manhole" involved. The demander believed that the reason was that the supplier did not manufacture according to the requirements of the design drawings and the design materials; while the supplier believed that it was caused by improper design standards selected by the designer and had no direct relationship with the manufacturing quality.
In order to find out the reasons for the bulging and deformation of the "manhole" involved in the case, the purchaser proposed to conduct quality appraisal. "
Identification analysis results:
The identification expert group's relevant information, on-site investigation and inspection results, and calculation results of the "manholes of vacuum distillation towers and vacuum stripping towers" involved in the case After discussion and comprehensive technical analysis, the following appraisal opinions were made:
1) The main reason for the bulging and deformation of the flange cover of the "manhole" involved in the case is that the lining layer is thin and cannot withstand the load under high temperature and negative pressure conditions, resulting in instability and deformation of the lining layer. At the same time, the difference in linear expansion coefficient between the stainless steel lining plate and the carbon steel body causes the deformation of stainless steel to be greater than that of carbon steel at high temperatures, which also causes bulging and deformation to a certain extent.
2) The main reason for the bulging and deformation of the flange of the "manhole" involved in the case is that the difference in linear expansion coefficient between the stainless steel lining plate and the carbon steel body causes the deformation of stainless steel to be significantly greater than that of carbon steel at high temperatures.